Some links on this site are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Herbal Supplements for Perimenopause Mood Swings: What the Evidence Shows

Adrian XH
Published Author, Certificate: Medical Research

Last updated

No herb has been proven to fix perimenopause mood swings. Black cohosh, St John’s wort and ashwagandha have the most research, but the results are mixed and each one has a real safety problem.

This page covers those three, the checks to do before you buy anything, and why herbs don’t replace a talk with your doctor. For hot flashes, sleep and hormone therapy, see our guide to natural perimenopause support.

Why do moods swing in perimenopause?

The National Institute on Aging says estrogen and progesterone decline greatly during the menopausal transition, and those changes may explain some symptoms. Most women start between ages 45 and 55, and symptoms can last two to eight years. (NIA)

On mood, the NIA says scientists don’t know why women feel moodier. Stress, family load, depression and tiredness could all play a part. It tells you to talk to your primary care provider or a mental health professional, because treatments exist.

Do herbs help perimenopause mood swings?

Sometimes, in small studies. Here is what the research shows for each herb.

HerbWhat the research showsMain safety flag
Black cohoshA 2007 review found lower depression and anxiety in the studies it covered. A 2012 Cochrane review of 16 trials found no clear gain over placebo for hot flushes or symptom scores.Liver injury, rarely severe
St John’s wortWorks about as well as standard antidepressants in people with major depression. Not tested specifically for perimenopause in the review below.Weakens many medicines, including birth control pills
AshwagandhaOne 8-week trial of 100 perimenopausal women improved symptom scores, including the psychological part.Liver injury, rarely severe

Does black cohosh help with mood?

The evidence conflicts. A 2007 review of botanicals for mood in menopausal women said black cohosh reduced depression and anxiety in every study it reviewed (Geller and Studee, Menopause).

But the Cochrane review pooled 16 randomized trials with 2,027 women. Black cohosh did no better than placebo on hot flush frequency or menopausal symptom scores, and the authors judged the evidence insufficient. The trials used a median of 40 mg a day (Leach and Moore, Cochrane 2012).

The liver risk is documented. LiverTox rates black cohosh category A, a well-established cause of clinically apparent liver injury. It lists more than fifty cases, from mild enzyme rises to liver failure needing a transplant or ending in death. Injury usually showed up within 2 to 12 weeks. It also notes that some products sold as black cohosh are mislabeled and contain other Actaea species (LiverTox).

If your skin or eyes turn yellow, stop and get medical care. Ask your doctor first if you have liver disease.

Breast cancer is a common worry. A 2013 systematic review found no link between black cohosh and higher breast cancer risk, but also found no evidence it helps hot flashes in women with breast cancer (Fritz et al.). If you’ve had breast cancer or take tamoxifen, ask your oncology team before you start.

Does St John’s wort help with mood swings?

For depression, yes. A Cochrane review of 29 trials with 5,489 people with major depression found extracts beat placebo and matched standard antidepressants, with fewer dropouts from side effects. The authors flag that German-speaking countries reported better results, which makes the picture harder to read (Linde et al.).

That result is about depression. The trials weren’t built around perimenopausal women.

The interactions are the bigger issue. The NCCIH says St John’s wort can weaken many medicines, including birth control pills, warfarin, some seizure, HIV and heart drugs. Combined with some antidepressants it may cause serious serotonin-related side effects. Use during pregnancy may be unsafe (NCCIH).

Birth control matters here because you can still get pregnant in perimenopause. The NIA says to keep using it for 12 months after your last period if you don’t want to conceive.

Does ashwagandha help?

One trial points that way. In 100 perimenopausal women, 300 mg of root extract twice a day for 8 weeks lowered total Menopause Rating Scale scores more than placebo, including the psychological domain. Estradiol rose and FSH fell. Ninety-one women finished (Gopal et al., 2021).

One 8-week trial isn’t enough to call it proven.

LiverTox rates ashwagandha category B, a likely cause of clinically apparent liver injury. Cases usually appeared 2 to 12 weeks after starting, with jaundice and itching. The jaundice was often prolonged but ultimately resolved. Fatal injury and transplants have been reported, particularly in people with existing liver disease. No serum enzyme rises were reported in clinical trials (LiverTox).

What should you do before taking any herb?

  • Ask a pharmacist or your doctor first if you take any medicine. The NHS says herbal products aren’t tested and regulated the way medicines are, and quality and ingredients can’t always be guaranteed (NHS).
  • Start one product at a time, so you know what caused any side effect.
  • Don’t stop a prescribed medicine to try a herb.
  • Stop and get medical care if you turn yellow.

Can herbs replace hormone therapy?

No. The Menopause Society’s 2023 position statement calls hormone therapy the most effective treatment for hot flashes and night sweats. Its panel did not recommend supplements or herbal remedies for them (Menopause Society 2023).

The Cochrane review also found hormone therapy beat black cohosh on symptom scores. If mood swings are hurting your life, ask your doctor about hormone therapy and the other options. Our natural perimenopause support guide lays them out.

Questions

How long do herbs take to work for perimenopause mood swings?

The ashwagandha trial ran 8 weeks. The black cohosh trials in the Cochrane review lasted 23 weeks on average. No herb has a proven timeline for mood.

Can I take black cohosh and St John’s wort together?

Don’t stack them on your own. St John’s wort interacts with many medicines and black cohosh carries liver warnings. Ask a pharmacist first.

Are herbal supplements safe for long-term use?

Safety data are thin. The Cochrane review called the safety evidence inconclusive because of poor reporting, and LiverTox documents liver injury with black cohosh and ashwagandha. Tell your doctor what you take.

Can herbs replace hormone replacement therapy?

The Menopause Society calls hormone therapy the most effective treatment for hot flashes and did not recommend herbal remedies for them. Talk to your doctor about your options.

When are mood swings more than perimenopause?

The NIA says stress, depression and tiredness can also cause mood changes. If your mood is low, severe or lasting, talk to your primary care provider or a mental health professional.